The Magazine

Pius XII and the Jews

Feb 26, 2001, Vol. 6, No. 23 • By DAVID G. DALIN
Widget tooltip
Single Page Print Larger Text Smaller Text Alerts

Pius XII and the Second World War

According to the Archives of the Vatican

by Pierre Blet

Paulist, 416 pp., $ 29.95


Constantine's Sword

The Church and the Jews: A History

by James Carroll

Houghton Mifflin, 576 pp., $ 28


Hitler's Pope

The Secret History of Pius XII

by John Cornwell

Viking, 430 pp., $ 29.95


Pope Pius XII

Architect for Peace

by Margherita Marchione

Paulist, 256 pp., $ 22.95


The Defamation of Pius XII

by Ralph McInerny

St. Augustine's, 223 pp., $ 19


The Catholic Church and the Holocaust, 1930-1965

by Michael Phayer

Indiana University Press, 328 pp., $ 29.95


Hitler, the War and the Pope

by Ronald J. Rychlak

Genesis, 470 pp., $ 26.95


Papal Sin

Structures of Deceit

by Garry Wills

Doubleday, 326 pp., $ 25


Under His Very Windows

The Vatican and the Holocaust in Italy

by Susan Zuccotti

Yale University Press, 352 pp., $ 29.95

Even before Pius XII died in 1958, the charge that his papacy had been friendly to the Nazis was circulating in Europe, a piece of standard Communist agitprop against the West.

It sank for a few years under the flood of tributes, from Jews and gentiles alike, that followed the pope's death, only to bubble up again with the 1963 debut of The Deputy, a play by a left-wing German writer (and former member of the Hitler Youth) named Rolf Hochhuth.

The Deputy was fictional and highly polemical, claiming that Pius XII's concern for Vatican finances left him indifferent to the destruction of European Jewry. But Hochhuth's seven-hour play nonetheless received considerable notice, sparking a controversy that lasted through the 1960s. And now, more than thirty years later, that controversy has suddenly broken out again, for reasons not immediately clear.

Indeed, "broken out" doesn't describe the current torrent. In the last eighteen months, nine books that treat Pius XII have appeared: John Cornwell's Hitler's Pope, Pierre Blet's Pius XII and the Second World War, Garry Wills's Papal Sin, Margherita Marchione's Pope Pius XII, Ronald J. Rychlak's Hitler, the War and the Pope, Michael Phayer's The Catholic Church and the Holocaust, 1930-1965, Susan Zuccotti's Under His Very Windows, Ralph McInerny's The Defamation of Pius XII, and, most recently, James Carroll's Constantine's Sword.

Since four of these -- the ones by Blet, Marchione, Rychlak, and McInerny -- are defenses of the pope (and two, the books by Wills and Carroll, take up Pius only as part of a broad attack against Catholicism), the picture may look balanced. In fact, to read all nine is to conclude that Pius's defenders have the stronger case -- with Rychlak's Hitler, the War and the Pope the best and most careful of the recent works, an elegant tome of serious, critical scholarship.

Still, it is the books vilifying the pope that have received most of the attention, particularly Hitler's Pope, a widely reviewed volume marketed with the announcement that Pius XII was "the most dangerous churchman in modern history," without whom "Hitler might never have . . . been able to press forward." The "silence" of the pope is becoming more and more firmly established as settled opinion in the American media: "Pius XII's elevation of Catholic self-interest over Catholic conscience was the lowest point in modern Catholic history," the New York Times remarked, almost in passing, in a review last month of Carroll's Constantine's Sword.

Curiously, nearly everyone pressing this line today -- from the ex-seminarians John Cornwell and Garry Wills to the ex-priest James Carroll -- is a lapsed or angry Catholic. For Jewish leaders of a previous generation, the campaign against Pius XII would have been a source of shock. During and after the war, many well-known Jews -- Albert Einstein, Golda Meir, Moshe Sharett, Rabbi Isaac Herzog, and innumerable others -- publicly expressed their gratitude to Pius. In his 1967 book Three Popes and the Jews, the diplomat Pinchas Lapide (who served as Israeli consul in Milan and interviewed Italian Holocaust survivors) declared Pius XII "was instrumental in saving at least 700,000, but probably as many as 860,000 Jews from certain death at Nazi hands."