The Blog

Marvel Comics and Manifest Destiny

Spider-Man is going to India. Just how universal are America's most cherished comic-book ideals?

11:00 PM, Jan 27, 2005 • By DAVID ADESNIK
Widget tooltip
Single Page Print Larger Text Smaller Text Alerts

The most important difference Spider-fans will notice between the Indian and American notions of destiny is the Indian belief that tyranny and evil are primal forces no less powerful than freedom and good. Yet there is also a considerable measure of doubt embedded in the American vision of progress. Although one scientific accident gave Spider-Man his powers, other scientific accidents were responsible for the creation of his arch-nemeses, Dr. Octopus and the Green Goblin. In the final analysis, that which makes Pavitr Prabhakar authentically Indian does not make him in any way un-American.

Today the Republic of India is the most populous democracy on the face of the Earth. Someday, it may rival the United States in terms of wealth and power. Conventional thinking suggests that the emergence of a second superpower would threaten the security of the United States of America. Yet if India's first superhero recognizes that with great power there also comes great responsibility, perhaps we should look forward to the emergence of an Indian superpower.

David Adesnik is a fellow at the University of Virginia's Miller Center of Public Affairs and an editor of