Log-In Email:    Password:    
  Remember me
Register  |  Forgot Password?  |  Change Password  |  Update Email
Will France Say Non to the EU Constitution?
Maybe so.
by Tim Lehmann
02/10/2005 5:44:00 PM

Increase Font Size

 | 

Printer-Friendly

 | 

Email a Friend

 | 

Respond to this article



With three countries already on board and a host of European countries facing referenda to ratify the proposed European Constitution, one would think that the ratification process in Europhile France would be relatively simple. However, despite a majority in parliament in support of the constitution, there is increasing disenchantment on both the left and right that could derail Chirac's plans for a successful summer referendum. Chirac cannot simply assume a oui result, as recent events and polls attest.

Perhaps most surprising is that some of the most vocal opposition to the constitution has come from the left. For the usually statist left, the proposed constitution is viewed as too liberal economically (i.e., not sufficiently dirigiste), and insufficiently attentive to "social priorities," like France's sacred 35-hour work week. Fueling attacks against the proposed constitution have been France's labor unions, twenty of which have launched a campaign against the constitution, claiming that the constitution "robs" countries of the right to govern themselves. Nearly 500,000 demonstrators recently took to the streets in Paris, Marseilles, and other major cities to protest the threat to the 35-hour work week that they believe the constitution poses.

Then, last week, the 120-member Committee of General Labor Confederation (CGT), which has many members in the influential state railway company SNCF, voted against the proposed constitution, in opposition to the wishes of the CGT's secretary-general. The CGT's vote is symptomatic of a larger change of opinion on France's left, captured by the fact that 56 of the leading opposition Socialist Party's (PS)

140 deputies flouted PS chief Francois Hollande last week by abstaining from a National Assembly debate on the proposed constitution.

On the right, opposition to the constitution is being spearheaded not only by Jean-Marie LePen's nativist National Front party, but also by proponents of French sovereignty like the conservative Philippe de Villiers. Even members of Chirac's own Union for Popular Movement (UMP), which largely supports the constitution, has created a "Group for a confederation of the states of Europe" that opposes the proposed constitution.

But perhaps most distressingly for Chirac is the fact that two recent examples of France's erratic voting behavior portend poorly for this summer's referendum. The 1992 Maastricht Treaty referendum, which led to a common European currency, barely squeaked through, and most likely would not have done so if the vote had taken place only a week later. Passage of the treaty had seemed a shoo-in for then-President Francois Mitterrand, who watched the treaty eventually pass by a meager one percent. And Chirac will be the last to write off the unpredictability of France's voters after the 2002 presidential elections, in which one in three voters went for either a far-left or far-right candidate in the first round of the presidential election, and the proto-fascist LePen maneuvered his way into the final round of the election against Chirac.

Conflicting polling data make it hard to judge current popular support of the constitution in France. While some polls show support hovering around 65 percent, others show a significant decline in support-an Ipsos poll showed support drop from 64 percent to 57 percent in December, and another showed a dip from 64 percent in the fall to 59 percent last month. A poll in France's metro revealed only 52 percent support, with 84 percent of those polled claiming they didn't know enough about the 300-plus page document. And it is surely not a good sign for the constitution's supporters that a recent poll by the Journal du Dimanche showed that 46 percent of the public is still undecided as to how they will vote, with only 25 percent certain that they will vote oui.



CONTINUED
1 2  Next >
Print This Article

  Clark Kent Meets Walter Duranty
Today, 1:24 PM
 
  Who's Making Iran Policy?
Today, 12:45 PM
 
  More on Palin
Today, 9:51 AM
 
  Kristol: A Contrarian Take
Yesterday, 5:06 PM
 
   


Search   Subscribe   Subscribers Only   FAQ   Advertise   Store   Newsletter
Contact   About Us   Site Map   Privacy Policy