The Suburbs from Hell
The GOP is in trouble in the districts around Philadelphia.
Oct 30, 2006, Vol. 12, No. 07 • By SONNY BUNCH
Bucks County, Pennsylvania
Of these GOP incumbents, the two who are clearly in trouble--Weldon and Sherwood--are in districts that are generally safe for Republicans. Weldon won in 2002 with 66 percent of the vote, and in 2004 with 59 percent, while Sherwood has run unopposed in the last two elections. Yet the most recent polling shows both of them trailing. Their downfall: the "culture of corruption."
Both men's opponents have been able to portray them as the local embodiment of Republican corruption, in a year when the Democratic leadership is making GOP sleaze a national issue. Their predicaments bring to mind that of another Pennsylvania incumbent defeated in a national sweep--Marjorie Margolies-Mezvinsky, the only Democratic incumbent in Pennsylvania to fall to the Gingrich revolution of 1994. A freshman representative, Margolies-Mezvinsky had cast the final vote to pass President Clinton's 1993 budget, whose massive tax increase helped provoke the Republican sweep. Made to personify the tax-and-spend Demo crats, she was handily defeated.
This year, Weldon and Sherwood have given their opponents the rope with which to hang them. Weldon's troubles came to a head on October 16, when the FBI conducted six raids as part of an investigation into whether he used his influence to gin up lobbying business for his daughter. Sherwood, embarrassed by a former mistress claiming he had assaulted her, has been forced to take to the airwaves and admit that yes, he had had a mistress, but no, he had not choked her.
Weldon and Sherwood seem doomed to be the Margolies-Mezvinskys of this cycle. Fitzpatrick and Gerlach, by contrast, have kept their noses clean. Consummate politicians, both have good images in the media and good rapport with their constituents. Instead of personal problems, they are up against the increasingly Democratic demographics of their districts.
Gerlach is running in a most peculiarly shaped district, with tentacles stretching north and south from its main body. "This is not a district drawn up in heaven," says Terry Madonna, director of the Franklin and Marshall Keystone Poll. Redrawn in 2002 specifically for Gerlach, the Sixth "has no core, no center," Madonna says, "and it's extraordinarily difficult to represent because of its diversity and complexity." It's also difficult to campaign in. In some neighborhoods you cross a district boundary every few blocks.
That hasn't stopped Gerlach from tireless campaigning. He both touts his local credentials and warns of the dire effects of a Democratic takeover of the House. Touring a packaging plant in Exton, Gerlach was informed that a constituent wanted to know why businesses should get involved in lobbying Congress and endorsing candidates. He chuckled and said, "Tell her to give me a call. I'll tell her what her world would look like with Nancy Pelosi as speaker of the House, and with Charles Rangel as chairman of the Ways and Means Committee." The Republicans' commitment to lower taxes, he stressed, would be good for both individuals and small businesses.
Gerlach is still ahead in most polls. The latest Keystone Poll puts him at 45 percent and his opponent, Lois Murphy, at 38 percent among registered voters, though his lead narrows to 3 points among likely voters. A recent Public Opinion Strategies poll of likely voters is more favorable--Gerlach leads Murphy 51 percent to 39 percent.
Mike Fitzpatrick is another Republican who should be in trouble simply because of demographics. His Bucks County district is populated mainly by commuters (to Philadelphia, New Jersey, and even New York), many of them young families who still vote Democratic even though they like safe suburbs and exurbs with good schools. He does hold one strong advantage, though: He's the only local candidate in the race.
When I asked him to compare his local record with that of his challenger, Iraq war veteran Patrick Murphy, he almost laughed. "He didn't grow up in the district. He made a politically calculated decision to move to the district, based upon an opportunity he saw for himself to run for the Congress."
Fitzpatrick, a former Bucks County commissioner, drove home that point in a debate earlier this month. Allowed to ask his opponent one question, Fitzpatrick chose not to delve into the vagaries of foreign policy or tax law. Instead, he asked Murphy, "How many school districts are there in Bucks County?" Flustered, Murphy was unable to respond.
Fitzpatrick has also managed to distance himself from President Bush on Iraq and has run TV ads portraying Murphy as indecisive on the issue. Larry Ceisler, a veteran Democratic political analyst, says Fitzpatrick runs into problems with the increasing share of his constituents who are liberal on social issues, but he has done a good job of racking up endorsements from disparate groups, including the Sierra Club, Defenders of Wildlife, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, and all five Fraternal Order of Police branches that endorse candidates. "I have both business, industry, and labor support," he says. "Not many Republicans have those kinds of endorsements or that kind of support."
Managing to insulate himself from national trends, Fitzpatrick has a simple campaign ethic: "You work hard, you're honest with people, you lay your record out in front of them, and you let them make a choice. And they'll make the right choice." It helps when you don't have to run advertisements explaining that you're not quite as morally bankrupt as you look.
Sonny Bunch is assistant editor at THE WEEKLY STANDARD.