The Magazine

Deal Breaker

Feb 11, 2013, Vol. 18, No. 21 • By FRED BARNES
Widget tooltip
Single Page Print Larger Text Smaller Text Alerts

It won’t lead to success. Obama would create a freeway to citizenship from day one. That’s a poison pill for Republicans. Scrapping the guest worker program would also alienate Republicans, the business community, and those conservatives who regard it correctly as an alternative to illegal border-crossing.

Obama didn’t talk about guest workers in his speech. But Richard Trumka, the head of the AFL-CIO, was sitting in front of him in Las Vegas when he spoke. Organized labor has long opposed the program and was instrumental in killing it in the 1960s.

The president’s motives are suspicious. In 2007, he backed a bipartisan bill, while voting for amendments certain to scare off Republicans. One was to kill the guest worker provision after five years. It passed by one vote. It wasn’t the only reason the bill ultimately died, but it was a factor.

Now Obama is demanding immigration reform be speeded up or he’ll unleash his own proposal. Coming from a president who promised to tackle immigration in his first year, then waited until after his reelection, this requires political moxie. He has plenty of that. Being accused of hypocrisy won’t faze him either.

Should Congress balk at his timetable, Obama is no doubt ready to blame Republicans. And he’ll blame them if Democrats adopt his recommendations, bipartisanship vanishes, and the legislation collapses. He may even blame Republicans if the bipartisan compromise becomes law. A better bill was available, he’ll argue, and Republicans blocked it.

Republicans needn’t worry. Nor should they expect Hispanic voters to swoon over their part in reforming immigration. Credit will come, over time, from having done the right thing for the right reason. Eleven million immigrants, having come to America to decide their own destiny in life, will recognize who and what made it possible.

Recent Blog Posts

The Weekly Standard Archives

Browse 18 Years of the Weekly Standard

Old covers