The Magazine

A Stellar Eclipse

The fault, dear moviegoers, is not in our stars

Sep 15, 2014, Vol. 20, No. 01 • By SONNY BUNCH
Widget tooltip
Audio version Single Page Print Larger Text Smaller Text Alerts

The multiplex in the age of brands—an era of sequels and prequels, of movies derived from comic books and board games, of repackaged and repurposed “intellectual property” that comes with “high pre-awareness” and appeals to “all four quadrants”—isn’t the friendliest place for movie stars. 

Tom Cruise in ‘Magnolia’ (2000)

Tom Cruise in ‘Magnolia’ (2000)

With very few exceptions, actors in these productions are more or less disposable. The star of the Transformers series was neither Shia LaBeouf nor Megan Fox but the digital effects; when director Michael Bay grew tired of the humans that were in front of the camera, he simply moved on to Mark Wahlberg and a lingerie model, respectively. The Chinese audiences for whom those films are actually made couldn’t care less about who is reading the script aloud. 

Over a span of less than a decade, Marvel has employed three different actors to play the Incredible Hulk in three different movies, and the gambit has paid off: Each film featuring the Hulk has grossed more than the last. Despite turning in a trio of huge hits as Jason Bourne, Matt Damon was replaced by Jeremy Renner in The Bourne Legacy. It didn’t matter that Renner’s character was of no relation to Jason Bourne; all that mattered was having “Bourne,” a word audiences recognized, in the title.

If we define movie stars as those who can open a film on their own—the sort that audiences see and say, “Yeah, I’ll give that a shot,” regardless of what the picture is about—then there are very few left. Sandra Bullock, certainly. Channing Tatum, perhaps. Jennifer Lawrence, maybe. Robert Downey Jr., of course. But the list is vanishingly small and only likely to get smaller as the years go on and brands grow in importance. 

Great acting and huge stardom are not exactly linked. The recently deceased Philip Seymour Hoffman, arguably one of the great actors of the last 20 years, didn’t put audiences in seats. His last, and possibly best, film, A Most Wanted Man, will earn less in its entire run than a movie about a talking tree and a snarky raccoon earned in its opening 24 hours. As compelling as he was, Hoffman wasn’t a star, at least not in the classic sense. Not in the sense that James Harvey means in his Watching Them Be. Not in the sense of John Wayne. 

“Nobody thought much about his acting .  .  . any more than they thought about Errol Flynn’s,” writes Harvey about Wayne. “As with Flynn, the charm and masculinity were more than enough.” It helped that Wayne had a mythmaker in the form of director John Ford to introduce him to the public in Stagecoach (1939):

A rifle report rings out, the coach slows—so does the cavalry escort behind—and comes to a halt. The rifleman (Wayne, as “the Ringo Kid”) looms in full-length close shot .  .  . in a white hat and black shirt, saddle and blanket under one arm, the other outstretched and gripping the rifle by the trigger guard: “Hold it!” he commands—twirling the rifle in his hand, looking straight ahead as the camera moves swiftly in on him until his close-up fills the screen, his neckerchief lifting in the wind. 

This sudden camera move (very un-Fordian) is like a nudge in the ribs: Look at this, will you? It not only rhymes with and takes up the stopped movement of the stagecoach, it seems meant to be starmaking.

Star power is hard to define but obvious when on display: I know it when I see it. As does Harvey, writing here about Greta Garbo: “Her close-ups become like arias, they can negotiate so many meanings. The ground of all of them, of course .  .  . is her extraordinary beauty.” The classic Hollywood stars were all beautiful in their own way: ruggedly masculine like Wayne or Clark Gable, innocently radiant like Ingrid Bergman, oddly but appealingly overemphasized like Bette Davis.

Working in a collaborative medium, film stars usually need a great director to wring out their best work. There was Wayne and Ford, of course, but also Bette Davis and William Wyler, and Marlene Dietrich and Josef von Sternberg. In the modern era, few pairings have been as successful as Robert De Niro and Martin Scorsese, who first worked together in Mean Streets (1973). Harvey recounts:

Earl[y] on [in Mean Streets] there’s a frenetic but dreamlike montage, to a percussive rock beat on the soundtrack, of Johnny Boy [De Niro], after one of his royal screwups, careering on foot through the nighttime Village streets, bumping into another guy going by, punching and mauling him almost in passing, then rocking on and appearing on a tenement rooftop next, raising his arms against the New York skyline first in a victory gesture, then a f— you one—before jumping down and leaving the frame.