The Blog

Expect: Greater Growth, a Lower Jobless Rate ...

And a higher interest rate?

12:00 AM, May 3, 2014 • By IRWIN M. STELZER
Widget tooltip
Single Page Print Larger Text Smaller Text Alerts

The economy grew in the first quarter at “point one percent,” announced Mitch McConnell, and then repeated it by way of introduction to an attack on President Obama’s economic policies. Whether seeming to revel in the misery of a slow recovery that has kept unemployment high and wages low simply because it drives the president’s approval rating down is good politics I leave to politicians, “that insidious and crafty animal, vulgarly called a … politician, whose councils are directed by the momentary fluctuation of affairs,” as Adam Smith put it.

Alternate Text field is required.      List     View     Edit  Title: * Teaser I

But it certainly is bad economics. It is foolish to plant one’s feet in the quicksand of one data point, Smith’s “momentary fluctuation”—unless one is prepared to congratulate Obama if the predicted spring rebound occurs as consumers make up for snow-bound time, as they seem to be doing.

A good number of economists are guessing that severe winter weather during the first quarter chopped 1.5 percent off that period’s GDP, one of the accurate statements made by Obama’s press secretary in recent weeks. Consumers couldn’t get to the shops, exports couldn’t get to ports or on the road to Mexico and Canada, two of America’s largest foreign markets. The Federal Reserve Board’s monetary policy gurus remain optimistic that “growth in economic activity has picked up recently,” an optimism supported by a slew of recent data.

·     The manufacturing sector expanded in April for the eleventh consecutive month.

·     Production, employment, and new orders in the Chicago area rose in April, a move, says Goldman Sachs, “consistent with brighter Philly, Richmond, and Dallas” regional results.

·     Personal incomes rose more than expected in March, led by wage and salary income.

·     Personal spending chalked up a solid gain since the end of the first quarter.

·     Exports have recovered from their Q1 collapse.

·     Orders for durable goods such as cars and fridges rose by 2.6 percent in March, the largest increase in six months, and car sales in April topped the winter months.

·     Consumer confidence remains close to a six-year high despite a slight dip in April.

If winter comes … well, you know the rest.

Perhaps most significant, real investors who put real money behind guesses as to the future of the economy discounted the poor Q1 report, and drove share prices to the first record-close of the year on the very day that the poor first-quarter GDP data were announced. Markets are far from an infallible guide to future economic activity, but then again neither are economic forecasts.

As is often the case, not all data point in one direction. In an interview prior to the annual meeting of his Berkshire Hathaway group, the fabled investor Warren Buffett pointed out that the housing sector is “not that strong. … The pickup is lower than I had anticipated.” Which is one reason some economists expect the recovery to remain feeble, with the economy growing at a rate of only some 2.3 percent, which compares with the 4.1 percent average for all post-1960 recoveries. 

The nil first quarter growth triggered a new round of the blame game, with winter weather only one of the perceived villains of the piece. Too-tight fiscal policy, too-high taxes such as those driving Pfizer to lower-tax Britain, too-pervasive regulation, and Obamacare are among the accused. To which Alan Greenspan, former chairman of the Federal Reserve Board, adds: uncertainty. He notes that businesses are spending on short-lived assets such as software, but not on long-lived assets such as plant and equipment. 

Yesterday a new jobs report provided ammunition to all parties to the debate on the near-term future of the American economy. In April the economy added 288,000 jobs, 273,000 of them in the private sector, with the gains spread widely among industries. The unemployment rate fell from 6.7 percent in March to 6.3 percent. Cheers from the optimists and from all the president’s men.

More important, respond the pessimists, are three facts lurking beneath the headline job-growth numbers: the fall in the labor-force participation rate, the plight of the long-term unemployed, and the poor quality of the jobs being created.

Recent Blog Posts

The Weekly Standard Archives

Browse 19 Years of the Weekly Standard

Old covers