Morning Jay: The DLC and Democratic Moderates, Reagan, and Sizing Up the GOP Field!
6:00 AM, Feb 9, 2011 • By JAY COST
1. Who's Extreme? For decades now, we have been told that the extremism of the conservative movement is so beyond the boundaries of rational political discourse that the Grand Old Party is set to fall into a pathetic, rump minority. Not coincidentally, these warnings have corresponded to the period when conservative have dominated the GOP, and the GOP has returned to parity or better with the Democrats.
Meanwhile, the Democrats are regularly celebrated as the party of moderation. Just recently, for instance, John Harris and Jim VandeHei, editors of Politico, explained to us that reporters are partial to Obama not because they have liberal biases but because they have pragamatic, moderate biases -- and, of course, Obama is just so gosh-darned centrist!
Also, which congressional leader isn't even talking with her moderate partisans? Nancy Pelosi, of course.
The lesson in all of this? Over the last 50 years there has been a noticeable increase in ideological polarization, one that has affected the Democrats just as much as the Republicans. As an unnamed Democratic source told NRO's Brian Bolduc on why the DLC is closing shop: “Both of the parties are increasingly ideologically homogeneous. There’s no longer a vibrant Ripon society in the Republican party, and that is in large part because you have the demise of the Rockefeller Republicans and the conservative Democrats.” Exactly. This is a trend that has affected both parties.
Yet extremism is ultimately in the eye of the beholder. The fact that the media is so focused on extremism in the GOP while the center is clearly collapsing in the Democratic Party as well says more about the media than either party.
2. Ronald Reagan...Democrat?! With Ronald Reagan's 100th birthday come and gone, it has been interesting to watch him be reinterpreted by liberals who, a generation ago, would surely have been his harshest critics. That's fine by me. I would much rather read arguments about how the 40th president was a moderate rather than, say, a racist. But Eugene Robinson takes things too far:
Read between the lines, and you can see that this column is not really about praising Reagan, but trashing the modern-day Republican party, which Robinson later says has "lost its mind." His point is that today's GOP is so extreme that not even Reagan would support it.
The evidence he marshals for this thesis is not very impressive: