The Blog

Senate, EPA, Treasury Websites Vulnerable to Phishing Scams

7:01 AM, Mar 10, 2014 • By JERYL BIER
Widget tooltip
Single Page Print Larger Text Smaller Text Alerts

Less than a month after the exposure of a widespread vulnerability on government "open data" websites, another perhaps even more insidious opening for abuse of government websites has come to light. The problem is known as an "unvalidated redirect," and has been found on the websites of the Environmental Protection Agency, the Treasury Department, and even the Senate, among others. The vulnerability is not a new one and could extend back months if not years, and is not an uncommon problem on commercial websites either.

A "redirect" is a web address that automatically opens a webpage or, in many cases, even a completely different website that the original address, or URL, indicated.  Generally when a government website directs a user to an external site, a warning or disclaimer appears alerting the user. For instance, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services website places a small "world" icon next to external links, and the site has a page explaining the disclaimer:

Other government sites follow a different protocol where a special disclaimer page is displayed for several seconds after the external link is clicked before the users is automatically taken to the new page or site.  While this protocol is not a problem in and of itself, if the website code does not restrict the ability to redirect only to sites approved by host sites, any web address can be substituted.  This can allow unscrupulous website operators to provide a link in a website or an email that begins with a legitimate government address, such as or, but then quickly and automatically transport users to any website they choose.

The website for the Senate is an especially serious example of this vulnerability because of the complete lack of a disclaimer on the "exit" page before the redirect takes place.  Senators often will direct website users to pertinent news articles, stories concerning constituent issues, or government services on other federal websites.  However, the following screen is all that users see before they are bounced to the new page or site:

Since the script for the exit page is not restricted, anyone can establish a link by entering a [web address] after this prefix:[web address]  For example, this link directs users to after bouncing off of  <>  But replacing "" with any website works just the same way to direct users to that site.  This opening could easily be exploited by inserting this type of link in a phishing email or a website and inviting users to simply click on what appears to be a Senate website address but in reality is a redirect to a phishing site.  At that point, personal information could be solicited with the apparent endorsement of the Senate.

A bold scammer could even explicitly tell users, for example, that "you will see a message that you are exiting the Senate web server system and being transferred to our secure data collection site." Without a restriction on redirect links or even a disclaimer, there is nothing to warn an unsuspecting user that the Senate is in no way connected with the linked site.

Recent Blog Posts

The Weekly Standard Archives

Browse 19 Years of the Weekly Standard

Old covers