Like a Virgin Island Resident
Lefty financier and congresswoman’s fiancée dodged U.S. taxes.
4:45 PM, Oct 15, 2010 • By ALANA GOODMAN
As far as liberal financiers go, you don’t get much more powerful than S. Donald Sussman.
Sussman’s fiancée, Rep Chellie Pingree (D-ME).
Since 1989, the hedge-fund billionaire has pumped millions into the coffers of Democratic politicians and their political pet projects. Sussman sits on the board of the Center for American Progress, the Democracy Alliance and the dovish Israel Policy Forum, and he’s been one of the top contributors to left-leaning 527 organizations during the 2010 election cycle.
But while Sussman has long kept a behind-the-scenes profile, a recent ethics controversy in Maine has flung him into the center of a complicated dispute over state residency, tax dodging and congressional ethics – the implications of which extend all the way from the rocky coast of southern Maine to the offshore tax haven of the U.S. Virgin Islands.
According to Sussman’s fiancée, Rep Chellie Pingree (D-ME), the philanthropist lives with her and has been a resident of Maine since 2009. But financial records and other documents indicate that Sussman has claimed full-time residency and extensive tax breaks in the U.S. Virgin Islands for years – and may be continuing to claim them.
Progressive organizations and Democratic leaders – including ones who have taken significant financial contributions from Sussman – have long vilified offshore tax havens, pointing to them as evidence of corporate greed gone wild. Rep. Pingree has been an outspoken critic of this type of tax evasion, and made it one of the cornerstones of her unsuccessful 2002 senate bid against Sen. Susan Collins (R-ME).
Confusion over Sussman’s residency status has been dogging his fiancée’s congressional reelection bid for weeks. As the former president of an ethics watchdog group, Pingree caught flack in late September after she was found to be traveling on Sussman’s private jet – an activity prohibited by election rules, unless the aircraft owner is a family member.
In response to Republican criticism over the incident, the congresswoman said that Sussman lives with her in Maine, which may qualify him as family. The House Ethics committee has since cleared her of any charges.
“[Sussman’s] primary residency is in Maine. That’s where he votes and that’s where his driver’s license is,” Pingree’s press secretary Willy Ritch told me.
Maine’s secretary of state Matt Dunlap, a Democrat, also confirmed that Sussman has been a state resident since 2009, and pays state income taxes.
But this seems to conflict with records that suggest a company owned by Sussman is currently receiving financial benefits in the U.S. Virgin Islands. A decade ago, Sussman founded Trust Asset Management, LLP., in St. Thomas, and began paying himself income from his Connecticut-based hedge-fund firm through it. As recently as September, Trust Asset Management LLP., was listed as an active beneficiary of the Virgin Island’s tax breaks, known as the Economic Development Commission (EDC) benefits.
U.S. Virgin Island tax attorneys said that in order to receive these benefits through the EDC, a company owner must be a “bona fide” resident of the territory – meaning that the individual needs to live in the area for more than six months out of the year. Legal experts also said that it’s not possible for someone to be a bona fide resident of the U.S. Virgin Islands, and be a primary resident of another state at the same time.
“For tax purposes an individual can have only one primary residence at any one time,” said Daniel J. Gravel, an attorney for BoltNagi PC, a St. Thomas-based firm that specializes in tax law. “[T]o allow otherwise would encourage people to take advantage of the EDC program and would certainly create an enormous amount of other potential loopholes in general.”
Sussman’s attorney denied that his client was currently receiving EDC tax breaks. He refused to comment on when those benefits had ended, or whether the philanthropist had ever received benefits in the first place.
Other information has added to the confusion over Sussman’s residency status. During an interview with the Virgin Islands Daily News in July, the hedge-fund owner reportedly told the paper that he has resided full-time in the territory since 2000.
“[Sussman] moved the operation of his financial business to Red Hook on St. Thomas around 2000 and has been a full-time resident ever since, he said,” the paper paraphrased in a July 19 profile of the billionaire.