May 26, 2008 • Vol. 13, No. 35 Download Now! (pdf)

 

COVER
Let a Thousand Posters Bloom
by Jonathan V. Last

EDITORIAL
Let's Drill
by Fred Barnes

UN to Burma: Drop Dead
by Matthew Continetti

SCRAPBOOK
New Jersey Hall of Fame, etc.

ARTICLES
What's Up, Doc?
by Joseph Epstein

Dueling Redbaiters
by Ronald Radosh

A Medal for Brass
by Nina Shea

Our Hopeless Energy Policy
by Irwin M. Stelzer

California's Gift to McCain?
by John McCormack

Red as in Rust
by Reuben F. Johhson

A Conspiracy So Lunatic...
by John H. Hinderaker

FEATURES
A Theme for McCain's Pudding
by Yuval Levin

BOOKS & ARTS
Big Bad John
by Robert D. Novak

Assassins' Trilogy
by Joel Schwartz

Animated Aristophanes
by Eli Lehrer

Americans Under Fire
by Mackubin Thomas Owens

Blessed to Give
by Martin Morse Wooster

CASUAL
Express Yourself
by Victorino Matus


« Required Reading 04/04/08 | Main | McCain's No Dole »

Think Progress Screws Up Again

Last week Think Progress blogger Amanda accused John McCain of plagiarizing a speech from Admiral Timothy Ziemer only to retract the story hours later. Amanda, last name unknown, had failed to check with McCain's office before running her "exclusive," and she failed even to check McCain's website to see if he had used similar language in the past. In fact, he had. In a 1995 speech to the VFW, a speech predating Ziemer's, McCain had uttered the same phrases he was now alleged to have plagiarized. Amanda apologized for her sloppy reporting, but apparently she didn't learn much from the episode.

Today she runs a story about North Carolina Rep. Patrick McHenry under the headline: "Rep. McHenry calls U.S. soldier in Iraq a ‘two-bit security guard.'"

Well, it isn't true. Think Progress provides the video, but at no point does McHenry indicate that the "security guard" is an American soldier. In fact, if Amanda had bothered to call McHenry's office, she would have learned that the security guard was one of the foreign contractors so reviled by the left--an individual who in any other circumstance Amanda would likely label a "mercenary." I did call McHenry's office and the congressman's press secretary offered this statement from his boss:

It was a poor choice of words to describe the foreign contractor, but anyone who was there knows that I delivered a speech praising the heroism and sacrifice of those who are serving our country in harm's way.

The choice of words does not paint McHenry in the most flattering light...calling a security guard a "two-bit security guard" isn't exactly a classy move. But once again, Think Progress has failed to maintain even the minimum standards of the profession. How Amanda got from "security guard" to "U.S. soldier" is unclear, unless it was only intended to smear, like the false accusation she leveled at John McCain last week.

Email the article Think Progress Screws Up Again to a friend:

Send this article to:


Your email address:


Message (optional):


 
Contributors
Editor:
Michael Goldfarb

Contributors:
Dean Barnett
Jennifer Chou
Brian Faughnan
Ulf Gartzke
Reuben F. Johnson
Thomas Joscelyn
Stuart Koehl
John Noonan
Bill Roggio
Samantha Sault
Search
Archives
Contact
wws@weeklystandard.com
Categories
Feeds: Atom | RSS
[What is this?]
Powered by
Movable Type 3.2