November 30, 2009 • Vol. 15, No. 11
Download Now! (pdf)

Contributors
Editor (on leave):
Michael Goldfarb

Deputy Editors:
John McCormack
Samantha Sault

Contributors:
Jennifer Chou
Brian Faughnan
Ulf Gartzke
Mary Katharine Ham
Reuben F. Johnson
Thomas Joscelyn
Stuart Koehl
John Noonan
Bill Roggio
Search
Archives
Contact
wws@weeklystandard.com
Categories
Feeds: Atom | RSS
[What is this?]



« Does the House Bill Fulfill Obama's Pledge to Bar Abortion Funding? Gibbs Won't Say | The Blog home page

Democrats to Allow Up-or-Down Vote on Stupak Amendment

Last night the Rules Committee agreed to allow an up-or-down vote on Bart Stupak's amendment to bar federal funding of elective abortions through the health-care bill. A number of the already-declared "no" votes had based their opposition on grounds other than abortion, so the Democrats simply couldn't afford losing 30 to 40 of their own members on the abortion issue alone. (Politico counts 23 Democratic "no" votes right now, so 18 of these 41 undecided Democrats would have to vote no to defeat the bill.)

One Democrat says the Stupak amendment has enough votes to pass, but it will likely be a close vote. This summer (when the GOP caucus had one more member), pro-lifers lost a vote to ban taxpayer-funding of abortion in Washington, D.C by a 216 to 213 margin. Of course, then a few Republicans weren't present for the vote, some people like Tim Ryan of Ohio voted against the bill because of "home-rule" issues, and the vote wasn't an up-or-down vote on a pro-life measure but rather an attempt to block the entire bill from proceeding. Stupak's amendment has a better chance of passing.

Update: This Politico post I link to above by Patrick O'Connor reports that the Stupak amendment "effectively bar insurers that participate in the exchanges from offering coverage for abortions." That's not quite accurate--the Stupak amendment bars plans purchased with federal subsidies from covering elective abortions. Insurers would be free to sell supplemental plans and private plans that cover abortions.

Email the article Democrats to Allow Up-or-Down Vote on Stupak Amendment to a friend:

Send this article to:


Your email address:


Message (optional):