The Magazine

Too Charitable

North Korea’s favorite philanthropists.

Nov 12, 2012, Vol. 18, No. 09 • By ETHAN EPSTEIN
Widget tooltip
Audio version Single Page Print Larger Text Smaller Text Alerts

North Koreans have been starving for nearly two decades. The worst period of famine, from 1994 to 1998, killed some three and a half million people, and chronic food shortages have persisted since then, with untold lives lost. Death tolls can understate human suffering, too: The millions who manage to survive chronic hunger still bear scars for life. One North Korean defector that I interviewed in Seoul several years ago, who had been a child in the mid-1990s, stood no taller than five feet—though judging by the size of his hands and his head, he should have been a much bigger man.

North Koreans and Mercy Corps take tea

Dave Malan

What to do about this catastrophe has vexed governments and NGOs since the onset of the famine. One thing is clear: Simply giving food to North Korea doesn’t work. The Kim regime controls the country’s food supply and dispenses it as it sees fit, feeding favored classes (the military, Pyongyang residents), while leaving others (particularly inhabitants of the country’s mountainous northeast, which it perceives as hostile) to starve. Perversely, food aid can thus serve to strengthen the regime, as it helps turn food into a weapon of social control. And all of this is further complicated by the fact that while the North Korean government is quick to tell the world that its population is hungry and to demand foreign aid, somehow the military, the network of gulags, and the nuclear weapons program always remain fully funded.

For these reasons, when a conservative party takes control of the government in Washington or Seoul, you’ll often see it limiting food aid programs. The vast majority of private aid agencies and NGOs also stay away from North Korea, determining that their hard work there will be ineffectual at best, and at worst, actively helpful to an evil regime.

With one prominent exception, that is: Mercy Corps, a well-regarded Portland, Oregon-based aid agency, has the closest relationship with the North Korean government this side of Beijing.

Founded in 1979 as the Save the Refugees Fund, Mercy Corps focuses, in its own words, on “disaster response, sustainable economic development, health services, and emergency and natural disaster relief.” Since its modest start as a charity devoted to helping refugees fleeing the Cambodian killing fields, it has grown into a major NGO with an annual budget surpassing $250 million. Mercy Corps operates in a host of troubled countries, including Afghanistan, Haiti, and Mali. In many respects, the organization’s integrity is unimpeachable: Charity Navigator gives it four stars out of four, recognizing Mercy Corps’s low overhead and high transparency.

Mercy Corps has been active in North Korea since 1996, when, according to David Austin, the group’s program director for the country, “a North Korean diplomat to the U.N. began reaching out to aid agencies requesting help with agricultural production, as there was a famine occurring in the country.” Since then, Mercy Corps has been deeply involved in North Korea, sending regular shipments of food, medicine, and plants. Earlier this year, it dispatched a large delivery of antibiotics and oral rehydration salts.

In a phone interview with The Weekly Standard, Austin described how Mercy Corps delivers its aid to North Korea. Actually, in point of fact, Austin described how Mercy Corps doesn’t deliver its aid to North Korea: Along with several other organizations, it simply ships the goods to a port in the country, where the Korean American Private Exchange Society, an arm of the North Korean foreign ministry, takes delivery and distributes them. Mercy Corps workers are not involved in the distribution. Instead, they are allowed periodic visits to the country to monitor the dispersal and use of the donated goods. But the itinerary is set long before the workers arrive in the country, and any changes have to be approved by officials. What’s more, the Mercy Corps workers are chaperoned by members of the North Korean foreign ministry and other officials the entire time they are in the country.

Austin concedes that North Korea is the only country in which Mercy Corps is not allowed to implement its own aid programs—only in North Korea does it simply trust the local regime to do what it says it will do. In every other country that it operates in, no matter how troubled—from Pakistan to Niger, from Burma to Colombia—Mercy Corps has permanent employees who oversee its aid programs. But not in North Korea—the regime won’t allow it. With the exception of infrequent, closely monitored visits, the Kim government has carte blanche to do what it sees fit with the aid. When asked about this stunning lack of oversight, Austin avers, “The [North Korean] government doesn’t take food away, to the best of our knowledge,” before quickly adding, “there’s no evidence of that.”

Recent Blog Posts

The Weekly Standard Archives

Browse 19 Years of the Weekly Standard

Old covers