Did the "System" Fail, Again?
We can’t keep relying on Lady Luck.
12:48 PM, May 4, 2010 • By THOMAS JOSCELYN
Faisal Shahzad, a 30 year-old naturalized American citizen from Pakistan, has been arrested as the chief suspect behind the failed car bomb attack on Times Square this past Saturday. The good news is, of course, that the bomb was fairly unsophisticated (showing a low-level of expertise), it failed to detonate (sparing the lives of New Yorkers and tourists), and the man believed to be responsible for assembling and deploying the car bomb was apprehended in short order. Authorities were able to pinpoint the would-be terrorist in impressively little time.
Alleged terrorist Faisal Shahzad.
It is not all good news, however. Law enforcement and intelligence officials failed to stop the perpetrator from placing his bomb in the first place. We were simply lucky that onlookers weren’t killed. If this was truly the work of a rogue individual, a “one-off” event as Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano suggested on Sunday, then that failure would be somewhat understandable. As law enforcement and intelligence professionals have repeatedly lamented, it is exceedingly difficult to stop a “lone wolf” terrorist.
Shahzad himself is reportedly telling that story to investigators. In interview sessions with the FBI, Shahzad has said that no one else was involved.
But what if Shahzad is simply lying and he was not a lone wolf? What if, as the press accounts are suggesting, there were more actors involved? What if this was yet another attack by the jihadists’ international terror network?
If that is the case, then this is a replay of the failed Christmas Day 2009 terrorist plot, when a would-be terrorist boarded a plane with a bomb that failed to detonate. Lady Luck and the vigilance of the passengers on board saved the day – not the U.S. government’s multi-billion dollar national security bureaucracy.
Press accounts say that Shahzad may have ties to foreign terrorists in Pakistan. For example, Fox News is reporting that there are arrests in Pakistan that are tied to the attempted bombing. And theWashington Post reports that investigators are:
The Post’s source says that we should think “smaller” than al Qaeda in terms of the organization that may be behind this latest attack. An alphabet soup of Islamist terrorist and extremist groups operates in Pakistan, with al Qaeda being the tip of the jihadist spear. So, Shahzad could have made contact with any one of those groups. Bill Roggio at the Long War Journal first reported that the Pakistani Taliban, which works closely with al Qaeda, claimed credit for the Times Square attack in a video that was apparently recorded beforehand. (See here for Bill’s excellent reporting.)
Whether the Pakistani Taliban or some other part of the jihadist hydra was behind Shahzad’s crude, yet potentially deadly, plot we cannot know for sure at this time. But if these early reports are correct, then we do know that one of two things happened: (1) our intelligence officials failed to detect Shahzad’s overseas terrorist ties, or (2) intelligence and law enforcement officials failed to act on them. Either way, the U.S. government was not able to stop a would-be terrorist before his finger was on the trigger.
Most troubling of all, Saturday’s attempt would mean that -- in the past six months alone -- there have been three terrorist plots against the American homeland with ties overseas that the Feds failed to unravel before the plot became live.
Recent Blog Posts